# 📋 Review & Opinion on CLI Option Redesign Proposal (Job 10a3201c)

- **Reviewer**: planner-reviewer-claude-01
- **Job ID**: 10a3201c
- **Role**: Planner & Reviewer
- **Target Proposal**: CLI Option Redesign (`--creator`, `--planner`, `--reviewer`)

---

## 1. Executive Summary & Verdict
- **Verdict**: **STRONGLY ENDORSED (100% PASS)**
- **Rationale**: The proposal resolves an asymmetry in the CLI design where the three fundamental roles were represented inconsistently (`--target-agent` vs `--plan` vs `--reviewer`). Transitioning to `--creator`, `--planner`, and `--reviewer` provides high ergonomic clarity and intuitive alignment with the architecture.

---

## 2. Key Architectural Strengths

1. **Role Symmetry (3-Tier Alignment)**:
   - `--planner <name>`: Explicitly binds the Planner session and implicitly sets `PLAN_MODE=true`.
   - `--creator <name>`: Explicitly binds the primary Creator session.
   - `--reviewer "A,B"` / `--all-reviewer`: Binds the Reviewer pool.

2. **Zero-Breaking-Change Guarantee**:
   - Preserving `--target-agent` as an alias for `--creator` guarantees complete backward compatibility for all existing scripts, tests, and wrapper invocations.

3. **Multi-Agent Disambiguation**:
   - In environments with multiple running Planner-capable agents (e.g. Claude + Grok + AGY), `--planner <name>` eliminates ambiguity and allows precise orchestration targeting.

---

## 3. Recommended Edge Case Defenses for Implementation

1. **Flag Mutual Consistency**: If both `--creator <name1>` and `--target-agent <name2>` are provided with conflicting names, `run_loop.sh` should fail-fast with a clear validation error.
2. **Implicit `--plan` Handling**: Providing `--planner <session>` should automatically set `PLAN_MODE=true`, but passing `--planner <session>` while simultaneously passing a hypothetical `--no-plan` should be rejected as contradictory.
3. **Session Liveness Validation**: When `--planner <session>` is explicitly supplied, `run_loop.sh` should verify that the specified session exists and has `status: running` in `agent-sessions.yaml`.

[VERDICT: PASS]
