diff --git a/.agents/reports/creator-agy-01/version-update-assessment.md b/.agents/reports/creator-agy-01/version-update-assessment.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cf239f2 --- /dev/null +++ b/.agents/reports/creator-agy-01/version-update-assessment.md @@ -0,0 +1,131 @@ +# πŸ“‹ Multi-Agent Mux 버전 μ—…λ°μ΄νŠΈ ν•„μš”μ„± 및 적정 버전 κ²€ν†  λ³΄κ³ μ„œ + +- **λ¬Έμ„œ ID**: `version-update-assessment-issue-3` +- **κ΄€λ ¨ μž‘μ—… ID (Job ID)**: `6c24ddd0` +- **μž‘μ„± μ—μ΄μ „νŠΈ**: `creator-agy-01` (`agy`) +- **κ²€ν†  λŒ€μƒ 컀밋 λ²”μœ„**: `0644e77..HEAD` (`c49ee3b`, `7e15081`, `94f2e21`) +- **μˆ˜μ‹  리뷰어**: `planner-reviewer-claude-01` (`claude`), `reviewer-creator-grok-01` (`grok`), `reviewer-opencode-01` (`opencode`) +- **μž‘μ„± μΌμ‹œ**: 2026-08-31 (KST) + +--- + +## 1. κ°œμš” 및 κ²€ν†  λ°°κ²½ (Executive Summary) + +λ³Έ λ³΄κ³ μ„œλŠ” Issue #3('[Bug] herdr 데λͺ¬ ν”„λ‘œμ„ΈμŠ€ 뢄리(setsid) λˆ„λ½μœΌλ‘œ μΈν•œ μ„Έμ…˜ 리셋 및 UUID λ―Έν• λ‹Ή μ„Έμ…˜ resume λ°λ“œλ½ 문제') 해결을 μœ„ν•΄ μˆ˜ν–‰λœ μ½”λ“œ λ³€κ²½ 사항(`c49ee3b`, `7e15081`)에 λŒ€ν•΄, **SemVer 2.0.0(유의적 버전 2.0.0)** λͺ…μ„Έ 및 λ³Έ ν”„λ‘œμ νŠΈμ˜ 릴리슀 관리 원칙에 μž…κ°ν•˜μ—¬ **버전 μ—…λ°μ΄νŠΈμ˜ ν•„μš”μ„± μ—¬λΆ€**, **적정 λͺ©ν‘œ 버전 번호**, 그리고 **3-Way Version Lockstep 적용 ν„°μΉ˜ν¬μΈνŠΈ**λ₯Ό μ’…ν•© κ²€ν† ν•œ κ²°κ³Όλ₯Ό μ œμ‹œν•©λ‹ˆλ‹€. + +### πŸ“Œ 핡심 κ²°λ‘  μš”μ•½ +1. **버전 μ—…λ°μ΄νŠΈ ν•„μš”μ„±**: **ν•„μˆ˜ (REQUIRED)** + - ν”„λ ˆμž„μ›Œν¬ λŸ°νƒ€μž„ μ§„μ‹€ 곡급원인 `.agents/skills/lib.sh` 및 볡원 μŠ€ν‚¬μ˜ 핡심 라이프사이클 슀크립트(`.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-resume/scripts/`)에 μ‹€μ œ λŸ°νƒ€μž„ 버그 μˆ˜μ •μ΄ λ°˜μ˜λ˜μ—ˆμœΌλ©°, μ‹ κ·œ νšŒκ·€ ν…ŒμŠ€νŠΈ(`test_h26`, `test_t14`, `test_t15`, `test_t16`)κ°€ μΆ”κ°€λ˜μ—ˆμœΌλ―€λ‘œ 릴리슀 νŒ¨ν‚€μ§• 및 버전 좔적이 λ°˜λ“œμ‹œ μˆ˜ν–‰λ˜μ–΄μ•Ό ν•©λ‹ˆλ‹€. +2. **적정 λͺ©ν‘œ 버전 번호**: **`v4.1.3` (PATCH Release)** + - 곡개 API의 ν˜Έν™˜λ˜μ§€ μ•ŠλŠ” λ³€κ²½(Breaking Changes) μ—†μŒ $\rightarrow$ MAJOR(`v5.0.0`) 배제 + - μƒˆλ‘œμš΄ κΈ°λŠ₯ μ„œλΈŒμ‹œμŠ€ν…œμ΄λ‚˜ μ‹ κ·œ μ—μ΄μ „νŠΈ μ–΄λŒ‘ν„° μΆ”κ°€ μ—†μŒ $\rightarrow$ MINOR(`v4.2.0`) 배제 + - κΈ°μ‘΄ 결함에 λŒ€ν•œ 100% ν•˜μœ„ ν˜Έν™˜ λ‚΄λΆ€ 버그 μˆ˜μ • $\rightarrow$ **SemVer 2.0.0 Β§6에 μ˜κ±°ν•˜μ—¬ PATCH(`v4.1.3`)κ°€ μœ μΌν•˜κ²Œ 타당함** +3. **ν˜„μž¬ μƒνƒœ μœ μ§€ 원칙**: + - λ³Έ λ‹¨κ³„μ—μ„œλŠ” μš”κ΅¬μ‚¬ν•­μ— 따라 μ‹€μ œ μ½”λ“œ/μŠ€ν‚¬/버전 νŒŒμΌμ„ μˆ˜μ •ν•˜μ§€ μ•Šκ³ , 리뷰어 만μž₯일치 ν•©μ˜ 수렴 ν›„ 후속 릴리슀 νŒ¨ν‚€μ§• μž‘μ—…μ—μ„œ 3자 동기화(3-Way Lockstep)λ₯Ό μ›μžμ μœΌλ‘œ 일괄 μˆ˜ν–‰ν•  것을 μ œμ•ˆν•©λ‹ˆλ‹€. + +--- + +## 2. λ³€κ²½ λ‚΄μ—­ 뢄석 (Detailed Code Diff Analysis) + +`v4.1.2` 릴리슀 컀밋(`0644e77`) 이후 ν”„λ ˆμž„μ›Œν¬μ— 반영된 핡심 λ³€κ²½ 사항은 λ‹€μŒκ³Ό κ°™μŠ΅λ‹ˆλ‹€: + +### 1) Item 1: Herdr 데λͺ¬ ν”„λ‘œμ„ΈμŠ€ κ·Έλ£Ή μ™„μ „ 뢄리 (`c49ee3b`) +- **μˆ˜μ • 파일**: [`.agents/skills/lib.sh`](file:///Users/godopu16/PuKi/laa/canary_projects/multi-agent-mux/.agents/skills/lib.sh#L207-L224) +- **λ³€κ²½ λ‚΄μš©**: `.mam/shim/herdr` ν…œν”Œλ¦Ώ λ‚΄μ˜ λΆˆμ•ˆμ •ν•œ `nohup "$REAL_HERDR" ... server >/dev/null 2>&1 & disown` ꡬ문을 파이썬 `subprocess.Popen(sys.argv[1:], start_new_session=True)` 기반의 μŠ€ν¬λ„ˆλ‘œ μ „λ©΄ ꡐ체. +- **영ν–₯도 뢄석**: + - `start_new_session=True`λŠ” μžμ‹ ν”„λ‘œμ„ΈμŠ€μ—μ„œ `os.setsid()`λ₯Ό ν˜ΈμΆœν•˜μ—¬ μ™„μ „νžˆ μƒˆλ‘œμš΄ ν”„λ‘œμ„ΈμŠ€ κ·Έλ£Ή(PGID) 및 μ„Έμ…˜ ID(SID)λ₯Ό λΆ€μ—¬ν•©λ‹ˆλ‹€. + - λΆ€λͺ¨ μ…Έμ΄λ‚˜ ν…ŒμŠ€νŠΈ ν•˜λ„€μŠ€ λŸ¬λ„ˆμ˜ μ‹œκ·Έλ„ λΈŒλ‘œλ“œμΊμŠ€νŠΈ(`SIGINT`/`SIGTERM`)κ°€ λ°±κ·ΈλΌμš΄λ“œ Herdr 데λͺ¬μœΌλ‘œ μ „νŒŒλ˜μ§€ μ•Šλ„λ‘ μ™„λ²½νžˆ κ²©λ¦¬ν•©λ‹ˆλ‹€. + - μ™ΈλΆ€ μΈν„°νŽ˜μ΄μŠ€λ‚˜ CLI 인자의 λ³€κ²½ 없이 λ‚΄λΆ€ 데λͺ¬ ꡬ동 μ‹ λ’°μ„±λ§Œμ„ κ°œμ„ ν•œ **μ „ν˜•μ μΈ ν•˜μœ„ ν˜Έν™˜ λ‚΄λΆ€ 버그 μˆ˜μ •**μž…λ‹ˆλ‹€. + +### 2) Item 2: Class A μ—μ΄μ „νŠΈ 0-turn resume fallback 및 Discovery Epoch κ°±μ‹  (`7e15081`) +- **μˆ˜μ • 파일**: + - [`.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-resume/scripts/resume_session.sh`](file:///Users/godopu16/PuKi/laa/canary_projects/multi-agent-mux/.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-resume/scripts/resume_session.sh#L50-L136) + - [`.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-resume/scripts/update_yaml_resumed.sh`](file:///Users/godopu16/PuKi/laa/canary_projects/multi-agent-mux/.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-resume/scripts/update_yaml_resumed.sh#L165-L178) +- **λ³€κ²½ λ‚΄μš©**: + - `resume_session.sh`: `resolve_session_id.sh` κ²°κ³Ό UUIDκ°€ λΉ„μ–΄μžˆλŠ” 경우, Class A μ—μ΄μ „νŠΈ(`agy`, `hermes`, `opencode`)λŠ” `create_session.sh --role` 호좜 μ‹€νŒ¨ λŒ€μ‹  `FRESH_SPAWN=1`둜 μ „ν™˜ν•˜μ—¬ `spawn-spec` λͺ…λ Ήμ–΄λ‘œ 자율 fallback 슀폰. + - `update_yaml_resumed.sh`: `--uuid` 검증 κ°€λ“œλ₯Ό μ™„ν™”ν•˜κ³ , `if not uuid:` 쑰건 ν•˜μ—μ„œ `herdr_session_epoch = epoch`, `herdr_session_created_at = now`, `session_id_source = 'pending-discovery'`, `session_id_verified = False`λ₯Ό μ›μžμ μœΌλ‘œ μž¬μ„€μ •. + - **Class B λΆˆλ³€μ„± 보쑴**: `claude`, `grok`은 κΈ°μ‘΄ `verify_session.py:99-101` escape hatch 및 `test_t8` 계약을 κ·ΈλŒ€λ‘œ μœ μ§€ν•˜λ©°, 미식별 μ„Έμ…˜μ— λŒ€ν•œ RC=1 hard-exit λ™μž‘μ„ λ°”μ΄νŠΈ λ‹¨μœ„λ‘œ 보쑴. +- **영ν–₯도 뢄석**: + - 0-turn μ€‘μ§€λœ Class A μ„Έμ…˜ 볡원 μ‹œ λ°œμƒν•˜λ˜ λ°λ“œλ½/κ°•μ œ μ’…λ£Œ 결함을 ν•΄μ†Œν•˜κ³ , `reconcile.sh`의 stale transcript 였인 맀칭을 λ°©μ§€. + - κΈ°μ‘΄ 정상 resume λ™μž‘μ΄λ‚˜ Class B μ—μ΄μ „νŠΈμ˜ 계약을 μ „ν˜€ μΉ¨ν•΄ν•˜μ§€ μ•ŠλŠ” **μ™„μ „ν•œ ν•˜μœ„ ν˜Έν™˜ 버그 μˆ˜μ •**μž…λ‹ˆλ‹€. + +--- + +## 3. SemVer 2.0.0 기반 적정 버전 κ²€ν†  (SemVer 2.0.0 Evaluation) + +유의적 버전 2.0.0 (Semantic Versioning 2.0.0) λͺ…세에 λ”°λ₯Έ 각 버전 κ³„μ—΄μ˜ 적합성 κ²€ν†  κ²°κ³ΌλŠ” λ‹€μŒκ³Ό κ°™μŠ΅λ‹ˆλ‹€: + +| 버전 λΆ„λ₯˜ | SemVer 2.0.0 κ·œμΉ™ | λ³Έ λ³€κ²½ 사항 ν•΄λ‹Ή μ—¬λΆ€ | 채택 μ—¬λΆ€ | 상세 λ…Όκ±° | +| :--- | :--- | :---: | :---: | :--- | +| **MAJOR (`v5.0.0`)** | **Β§8**: 곡개 API에 κΈ°μ‘΄κ³Ό ν˜Έν™˜λ˜μ§€ μ•ŠλŠ” λ³€κ²½(Breaking Changes)이 λ„μž…λ  λ•Œ 증가 | ❌ ν•΄λ‹Ή μ—†μŒ | **기각** | - κΈ°μ‘΄ CLI ν”Œλž˜κ·Έ, YAML μŠ€ν‚€λ§ˆ, μ–΄λŒ‘ν„° μΈν„°νŽ˜μ΄μŠ€ 일체 보쑴
- Class B(`claude`, `grok`)의 κΈ°μ‘΄ λ™μž‘ 및 검증 계약 100% λΆˆλ³€
- μ‚¬μš©μž μ›Œν¬ν”Œλ‘œμš°μ— 파괴적 λ³€κ²½ μ—†μŒ | +| **MINOR (`v4.2.0`)** | **Β§7**: 곡개 API에 ν•˜μœ„ ν˜Έν™˜μ„±μ„ μœ μ§€ν•˜λŠ” μ‹ κ·œ κΈ°λŠ₯이 μΆ”κ°€λ˜κ±°λ‚˜ λŒ€κ·œλͺ¨ μ„œλΈŒμ‹œμŠ€ν…œμ΄ 신섀될 λ•Œ 증가 | ❌ ν•΄λ‹Ή μ—†μŒ | **기각** | - μ‹ κ·œ μ—μ΄μ „νŠΈ μ–΄λŒ‘ν„° μΆ”κ°€ μ—†μŒ (v4.1.0 OpenCode 좔가와 ꡬ별)
- μ‹ κ·œ CLI λͺ…λ Ήμ–΄λ‚˜ μŠ€ν‚¬ μ‹ μ„€ μ—†μŒ
- κΈ°μ‘΄ resume 슀크립트의 비정상 μ’…λ£Œ 버그λ₯Ό 정상 λ™μž‘ν•˜λ„λ‘ λ‚΄λΆ€ λΆ„κΈ° μ²˜λ¦¬ν•œ κ²ƒμž„ | +| **PATCH (`v4.1.3`)** | **Β§6**: ν•˜μœ„ ν˜Έν™˜μ„±μ„ μœ μ§€ν•˜λŠ” 버그 μˆ˜μ •(Bug Fixes)만 포함될 λ•Œ 증가 | βœ… **μ™„μ „ 일치** | **적합 (선택)** | - Issue #3의 2λŒ€ 결함(데λͺ¬ μ‹œκ·Έλ„ μ „νŒŒ 사망, 0-turn resume λ°λ“œλ½)에 λŒ€ν•œ 순수 결함 μˆ˜μ •
- κΈ°μ‘΄ 곡개 μΈν„°νŽ˜μ΄μŠ€ μ™„λ²½ ν˜Έν™˜
- 455개 전체 ν…ŒμŠ€νŠΈ μŠ€μœ„νŠΈ 100% 무결점 톡과 | + +λ”°λΌμ„œ 유의적 버전 κ·œμΉ™ 및 업계 ν‘œμ€€μ— λ”°λ₯Έ κ°€μž₯ μ •ν™•ν•˜κ³  νƒ€λ‹Ήν•œ λͺ©ν‘œ 버전은 **`v4.1.3` (PATCH)** μž…λ‹ˆλ‹€. + +--- + +## 4. 3-Way Version Lockstep 동기화 ν„°μΉ˜ν¬μΈνŠΈ λͺ…μ„Έ + +λ³Έ ν”„λ‘œμ νŠΈλŠ” 버전 일관성 μœ μ§€λ₯Ό μœ„ν•΄ `test_version_consistency.py`λ₯Ό 톡해 **3자 λ½μŠ€ν…(3-Way Version Lockstep)**을 κ°•μ œν•©λ‹ˆλ‹€. 후속 릴리슀 νŒ¨ν‚€μ§• μž‘μ—… μ‹œ μ•„λž˜ 지점듀이 μ›μžμ μœΌλ‘œ κ°±μ‹ λ˜μ–΄μ•Ό ν•©λ‹ˆλ‹€: + +### 1) λŸ°νƒ€μž„ μ§„μ‹€ 곡급원 (Single Source of Truth) +- [`.agents/skills/lib.sh`](file:///Users/godopu16/PuKi/laa/canary_projects/multi-agent-mux/.agents/skills/lib.sh#L16) + ```bash + MAM_VERSION="4.1.3" + ``` + +### 2) 버전 이λ ₯ 및 맀트릭슀 (`VERSIONS.md`) +- [`VERSIONS.md`](file:///Users/godopu16/PuKi/laa/canary_projects/multi-agent-mux/VERSIONS.md) + - Line 9: `- **ν”„λ ˆμž„μ›Œν¬ 버전**: `v4.1.3`` + - Line 10: `- **μ΅œμ‹  릴리슀 μΌμ‹œ**: 2026-08-31 (KST)` + - Line 15: `lib.sh λ‚΄ MAM_VERSION="4.1.3" λŸ°νƒ€μž„ μ§„μ‹€ 곡급원 μ •μ˜...` + - Line 21: `... ν‘œμ€€ν™”λ₯Ό 톡해 v4.1.3으둜 λ™κΈ°ν™”λ˜μ–΄ λ°°ν¬λ©λ‹ˆλ‹€.` + - Line 23~33: 8개 μŠ€ν‚¬ 버전 맀트릭슀 ν‘œ 전체 `4.1.2` $\rightarrow$ `4.1.3` κ°±μ‹  + - Line 38 상단: μ‹ κ·œ `v4.1.3` 릴리슀 μ²΄μΈμ§€λ‘œκ·Έ μ„Ήμ…˜ μ‚½μž… + +### 3) 8개 μŠ€ν‚¬ 메타데이터 (`SKILL.md` frontmatter) +- `.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-create/SKILL.md`: `version: 4.1.3` +- `.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-stop/SKILL.md`: `version: 4.1.3` +- `.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-resume/SKILL.md`: `version: 4.1.3` +- `.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-status/SKILL.md`: `version: 4.1.3` +- `.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-monitor/SKILL.md`: `version: 4.1.3` +- `.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-delegate-job/SKILL.md`: `version: 4.1.3` +- `.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-loop/SKILL.md`: `version: 4.1.3` +- `.agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-orc-onboard/SKILL.md`: `version: 4.1.3` + +### 4) μžλ™ν™” 검증 계약 +- [`tests/test_version_consistency.py`](file:///Users/godopu16/PuKi/laa/canary_projects/multi-agent-mux/tests/test_version_consistency.py): + - `test_three_way_version_lockstep()`: `lib.sh(MAM_VERSION)` == `VERSIONS.md(Current + Matrix 8 items)` == `8x SKILL.md frontmatters` 100% 일치 검증 + - `test_mam_version_is_not_env_overridable()`: ν™˜κ²½λ³€μˆ˜ μœ„μ‘° 차단 검증 + +--- + +## 5. `VERSIONS.md` 반영용 `v4.1.3` μ²΄μΈμ§€λ‘œκ·Έ μ΄ˆμ•ˆ + +후속 릴리슀 μž‘μ—… μ‹œ `VERSIONS.md`에 좔가될 ν‘œμ€€ λ³€κ²½ 이λ ₯ μ΄ˆμ•ˆμž…λ‹ˆλ‹€: + +```markdown +### πŸ› οΈ `v4.1.3` β€” Herdr Daemon Isolation & Class A 0-Turn Resume Reliability Fixes (2026-08-31) + +> **μ£Όμš” λ§ˆμΌμŠ€ν†€ (PATCH Release)**: Issue #3 결함 ν•΄μ†Œ β€” Herdr λ°±κ·ΈλΌμš΄λ“œ 데λͺ¬μ˜ `start_new_session=True` 기반 ν”„λ‘œμ„ΈμŠ€ κ·Έλ£Ή(setsid) μ™„μ „ 격리, Class A(`agy`, `hermes`, `opencode`) μ—μ΄μ „νŠΈ 0-turn 쀑지 μ„Έμ…˜μ˜ `FRESH_SPAWN` fallback 및 discovery epoch μ›μžμ  μž¬μ„€μ •, Class B(`claude`, `grok`) 계약 λΆˆλ³€ 보쑴, 455개 전체 ν…ŒμŠ€νŠΈ μŠ€μœ„νŠΈ 100% PASS 달성. + +#### 🩹 버그 μˆ˜μ • 및 μ•ˆμ •μ„± κ°œμ„  (Bug Fixes & Resilience) +* **C-1: Herdr 데λͺ¬ ν”„λ‘œμ„ΈμŠ€ κ·Έλ£Ή(PGID/SID) μ™„μ „ 뢄리 (`lib.sh`)**: + - `.mam/shim/herdr` ν…œν”Œλ¦Ώμ˜ `nohup ... & disown` 슀폰 방식을 파이썬 `subprocess.Popen(..., start_new_session=True)` 기반 μ „μš© μŠ€ν¬λ„ˆλ‘œ λŒ€μ²΄ν•˜μ—¬ μžμ‹ ν”„λ‘œμ„ΈμŠ€μ—μ„œ `os.setsid()` 호좜 보μž₯. + - λΆ€λͺ¨ μ…Έμ΄λ‚˜ ν…ŒμŠ€νŠΈ λŸ¬λ„ˆμ˜ μ‹œκ·Έλ„ λΈŒλ‘œλ“œμΊμŠ€νŠΈ(`SIGTERM`/`SIGINT`)둜 인해 λ°±κ·ΈλΌμš΄λ“œ Herdr 데λͺ¬μ΄ 예기치 μ•Šκ²Œ μ’…λ£Œλ˜λŠ” 결함을 μ›μ²œ 차단 (`test_h26`). +* **C-2: Class A μ—μ΄μ „νŠΈ 0-turn resume 자율 Fallback 및 Discovery Watermark κ°±μ‹  (`resume_session.sh`, `update_yaml_resumed.sh`)**: + - λŒ€ν™” 턴이 λ°œμƒν•˜κΈ° 전에 μ€‘μ§€λœ Class A(`agy`, `hermes`, `opencode`) μ„Έμ…˜ resume μ‹œ, UUID 미쑴재둜 μΈν•œ 비정상 hard-fail(RC=1) λŒ€μ‹  `FRESH_SPAWN=1`둜 μžλ™ μ „ν™˜ν•˜μ—¬ `spawn-spec` 기반의 정상 재슀폰 μˆ˜ν–‰ (`test_t14`). + - fresh-spawn resume μ‹œ `update_yaml_resumed.sh`μ—μ„œ `herdr_session_epoch`λ₯Ό resume μ‹œμ μ˜ νƒ€μž„μŠ€νƒ¬ν”„λ‘œ μ¦‰μ‹œ κ°±μ‹ ν•˜κ³  `session_id_source: pending-discovery`둜 μž¬μ„€μ •ν•˜μ—¬, μ„Έμ…˜ 생성과 볡원 사이에 μƒμ„±λœ λ¬΄κ΄€ν•œ 이전 λŒ€ν™” 파일이 `reconcile.sh`의 discovery sweep에 μ˜ν•΄ 였인 μΊ‘μ²˜λ˜λŠ” 것을 λ°©μ§€ (`test_t16`). + - Class B(`claude`, `grok`) μ—μ΄μ „νŠΈμ˜ `verify_session.py:99-101` assigned escape hatch 및 `test_t8` 계약은 μˆ˜μ • 없이 μ™„λ²½νžˆ 보쑴 (`test_t15`). +``` + +--- + +## 6. κ²°λ‘  및 ν”Όμ–΄ 리뷰 μš”μ²­ (Conclusion & Consensus Request) + +1. **μ΅œμ’… κ²°λ‘ **: + - Issue #3의 μˆ˜μ • 사항은 ν”„λ ˆμž„μ›Œν¬μ˜ 핡심 μ‹€ν–‰ 라이프사이클에 직접적인 영ν–₯을 λ―ΈμΉ˜λŠ” μ€‘μš”ν•œ μ•ˆμ •μ„± κ°œμ„ μ΄λ―€λ‘œ 버전 μ—…λ°μ΄νŠΈκ°€ ν•„μˆ˜μ μž…λ‹ˆλ‹€. + - λ³€κ²½μ˜ 성격은 100% ν•˜μœ„ ν˜Έν™˜μ„±μ„ μœ μ§€ν•˜λŠ” 결함 μˆ˜μ •μ΄λ―€λ‘œ, **`v4.1.3` (PATCH)** 둜 νŒμ •ν•˜λŠ” 것이 SemVer 2.0.0 κ·œμΉ™μ— λΆ€ν•©ν•©λ‹ˆλ‹€. +2. **리뷰어 ν”Όμ–΄ 리뷰 μš”μ²­**: + - `planner-reviewer-claude-01`, `reviewer-creator-grok-01`, `reviewer-opencode-01` μ„Έ λ¦¬λ·°μ–΄κ»˜ λ³Έ κ²€ν†  λ³΄κ³ μ„œμ˜ 버전 νŒμ • 논리(`v4.1.3` PATCH) 및 3-Way Lockstep κ³„νšμ— λŒ€ν•œ 검토와 ν•©μ˜λ₯Ό μš”μ²­λ“œλ¦½λ‹ˆλ‹€. diff --git a/.agents/reports/planner-reviewer-claude-01/report-39439652.md b/.agents/reports/planner-reviewer-claude-01/report-39439652.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3dc31f0 --- /dev/null +++ b/.agents/reports/planner-reviewer-claude-01/report-39439652.md @@ -0,0 +1,50 @@ +# πŸ” Cross-Review β€” Version Update Assessment for Issue #3 Fix (Job `39439652`) + +- **Reviewer**: `planner-reviewer-claude-01` +- **Target**: `.agents/reports/creator-agy-01/version-update-assessment.md` β€” an analysis-only deliverable (no version/code files touched, per its own Β§1 requirement) determining whether and to what version the already-committed Issue #3 fixes (`c49ee3b`, `7e15081`) should bump. +- **Method**: independently re-verified every factual claim against live git history and the current repo state β€” I authored/implemented and already exhaustively reviewed the underlying code changes this report is assessing (jobs `a9c8d6d3`, `398afb2e`), so my focus here is the version-classification judgment and the report's own factual citations, not re-deriving the code's correctness from scratch. + +--- + +## 1. Scope compliance + +`git status` shows exactly one new file (`version-update-assessment.md`) β€” no `lib.sh`, `VERSIONS.md`, or `SKILL.md` touched. Correctly honors the brief's explicit "do not modify version files yet" constraint. + +## 2. Commit-citation accuracy + +Verified both cited commits directly via `git show --stat`: +- `c49ee3b` β€” "fix(herdr): detach daemon bootstrap into own process group via python spawner" β€” matches the report's Item 1 description exactly (file list: `lib.sh` + `test_herdr_shim_contract.py`, +61/-3... consistent with the `nohup`β†’`Popen` swap and `test_h26`). +- `7e15081` β€” "fix(resume): allow fresh spawn fallback and refresh epoch on 0-turn Class A resume" β€” matches Item 2 exactly (file list: `resume_session.sh` + `update_yaml_resumed.sh` + `test_uuid_target.py`, consistent with `test_t14`/`t15`/`t16`). + +Both commits are real, on `main`, authored by the same identity as this session, and match the report's descriptions precisely β€” no fabricated or mischaracterized history. + +## 3. SemVer classification β€” sound + +Independently re-derived the same conclusion before reading the report's own table, then compared: no public CLI flag, YAML schema surface, or adapter interface was removed or made incompatible (MAJOR correctly excluded); no new agent adapter, skill, or subsystem was added β€” only an internal branch that turns a previously-hard-failing input into a successful one, which is squarely "internal change that fixes incorrect behavior" under SemVer 2.0.0 Β§6 (MINOR correctly excluded, PATCH correctly selected). I also checked the one subtlety worth checking β€” whether making a previously RC=1 case now RC=0 could itself be considered a breaking behavior change for a caller relying on the failure β€” but no other script in the codebase depends on `resume_session.sh`'s old hard-fail for this specific 0-turn case (confirmed in job `a9c8d6d3`'s original implementation review), so this doesn't push the classification toward MAJOR. **`v4.1.3` PATCH is the correct target.** + +## 4. Lockstep touchpoint accuracy + +- `lib.sh:32` (not the report's cited line 16, but functionally the same single-line constant β€” the report cites an older/different line reference; the field itself and its value are correct) β€” re-checked: `MAM_VERSION="4.1.2"` is the current baseline, confirming the proposed `"4.1.3"` bump target is a clean +1 patch. +- `VERSIONS.md` lines 9-10 and the 8-row skill matrix (lines ~23-33) match the report's citations exactly against the live file β€” I re-read the current file directly rather than trusting the line numbers. +- All 8 `SKILL.md` paths exist and currently read `version: 4.1.2`, confirmed by direct grep against every one of the 8 files listed in Β§4.3 of the report. +- `tests/test_version_consistency.py::test_three_way_version_lockstep` and `::test_mam_version_is_not_env_overridable` both exist exactly as cited and currently pass at the v4.1.2 baseline (re-ran directly). + +One minor, very small citation slip: the report says `lib.sh#L16` for `MAM_VERSION`; the live constant is actually at line 32. Non-blocking β€” the constant name/value/file are all correct, only the specific line number is off, and it doesn't affect the touchpoint list's completeness or the release-packaging job that will act on it (that job will grep for `MAM_VERSION=`, not hardcode a line number). + +## 5. Regression baseline + +Re-ran the full suite myself at current HEAD (not trusting the report's "455/455" claim): **455 passed, 0 failed**, 12m06s. Matches exactly. + +## 6. Changelog draft quality + +The Β§5 `v4.1.3` changelog draft is accurate to the actual changes (correctly attributes `test_h26`/`test_t14`/`test_t16` to their respective fixes, correctly notes Class B preservation), well-formatted, and consistent with this project's existing changelog style (compare the v4.1.2 entry's structure). No factual errors found in it. + +## 7. Minor non-blocking nit + +The report embeds several `file:///Users/godopu16/...` absolute local-machine links. Harmless for this session's reviewers (all operating on the same checkout) but not portable if this document is read outside this machine β€” purely cosmetic, doesn't affect the report's conclusions or the touchpoints it enumerates. + +## 8. Verdict + +The version-update-assessment report is factually accurate on every commit citation, file/line touchpoint, and test claim I checked, and its SemVer reasoning (v4.1.3 PATCH) is correct and well-argued β€” independently re-derived by me before cross-checking against the report's own table, with the same result. One trivial line-number citation slip (`lib.sh#L16` vs. the actual `:32`) does not affect the touchpoint list's usability. Full suite reconfirmed green (455/455) at current HEAD. I concur with the report's recommendation: **target `v4.1.3` (PATCH)** for the follow-up release-packaging job, using the enumerated 3-way lockstep touchpoints and the drafted changelog entry. + +[VERDICT: PASS] diff --git a/.agents/reports/reviewer-creator-grok-01/report-ec2e02e2.md b/.agents/reports/reviewer-creator-grok-01/report-ec2e02e2.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9ab77f5 --- /dev/null +++ b/.agents/reports/reviewer-creator-grok-01/report-ec2e02e2.md @@ -0,0 +1,40 @@ +# Cross-review: Issue #3 version-update assessment (`v4.1.3` PATCH) + +- **Reviewer**: `reviewer-creator-grok-01` +- **Job**: `ec2e02e2` +- **Target**: `.agents/reports/creator-agy-01/version-update-assessment.md` (job `6c24ddd0`) +- **Method**: independent SemVer read from `git log 0644e77..HEAD`, live `lib.sh`/`VERSIONS.md`/`resume_session.sh`, not the assessment at face value. + +--- + +## Independent SemVer recommendation + +**Bump is required. Target: `v4.1.3` (PATCH).** Same conclusion as the assessment. + +| Check | Evidence | +|---|---| +| Current release | `0644e77` shipped **`MAM_VERSION="4.1.2"`**. Issue #3 code is **after** that tag (`c49ee3b`, `7e15081`). Shipping those commits still labeled 4.1.2 would misidentify the release. | +| `c49ee3b` | Shim daemon spawn: `nohup&disown` β†’ `Popen(..., start_new_session=True)`. No CLI/YAML/`--agent` change. | +| `7e15081` | Class A empty-UUID resume: RC=1 β†’ `spawn-spec` fallback; optional `--cmd-full`; epoch reset. Class B `verify_session.py:99-101` and `test_t8` untouched. | +| MAJOR Β§8 | No removed flags, no removed `--agent` values, no YAML key deletions. Class B still hard-exits when truly unresolvable (`test_t15`). | +| MINOR Β§7 | No new agent/skill/command. Optional `--cmd-full` on `update_yaml_resumed.sh` is an internal helper, additive. Class A success-on-empty-UUID is a **bugfix of a documented recovery hole**, not a new subsystem (unlike `v4.1.0` OpenCode). | +| PATCH Β§6 | Matches v4.1.1 / v4.1.2 reliability PATCH precedent. | + +This reviewer’s vote: **`v4.1.3` PATCH**. Not 4.2.0. Not 5.0.0. Do not leave 4.1.2 on the Issue #3 commits. + +## Assessment accuracy + +The Β§3 table (MAJOR/MINOR/PATCH) and Β§5 changelog draft match the live diffs. Lockstep inventory (8 `SKILL.md` frontmatters, `VERSIONS.md` header + **line 21 prose** + 8-row matrix + new changelog, `test_version_consistency.py`) is the right edit surface. Deferring the actual bump until consensus is correct for this job’s β€œdo not mutate version files” constraint. + +## Nits (do not flip the class) + +- **`lib.sh` is line 32, not 16.** Β§4.1 cites `#L16`. Line 16 is header commentary; `MAM_VERSION="4.1.2"` is **line 32**. Packaging must edit 32 (same class of gotcha as VERSIONS.md line-21/24 prose). +- **Resume `SKILL.md` body** still says empty UUID β†’ `multi-agent-mux-create` (line 55). `resume_session.sh` now succeeds for Class A. Add that doc update to the packaging checklist (frontmatter-only lockstep will not catch it). +- Range `0644e77..HEAD` also contains `50a9f32` (v4.1.2 report archive); omitted from the commit list. Harmless. +- **455 tests**: not re-run in this job. Prior Issue #3 targeted run was 20 passed. Do not treat 455 as independently verified here. + +No `[ESCALATE: PLANNER]`. + +--- + +[VERDICT: PASS] diff --git a/.agents/reports/reviewer-opencode-01/report-71a1b000.md b/.agents/reports/reviewer-opencode-01/report-71a1b000.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d77fc52 --- /dev/null +++ b/.agents/reports/reviewer-opencode-01/report-71a1b000.md @@ -0,0 +1,48 @@ +# πŸ” Cross-Review + Independent Reviewer Opinion: Version Update Assessment for Issue #3 Commits (Job 71a1b000) + +- **Reviewer**: `reviewer-opencode-01` (role: reviewer) β€” this report serves both as a cross-review of the assessment document and as my independent reviewer opinion for the requested consensus. +- **Target**: `.agents/reports/creator-agy-01/version-update-assessment.md` (job `6c24ddd0`, `creator-agy-01`) β€” assessment-only deliverable (no code/version-file mutations permitted), evaluating commits `c49ee3b` + `7e15081` (+ docs `94f2e21`) for version-bump necessity and target version. +- **Method**: Every claim re-verified from live source and my own runs β€” commit contents, public-surface diff analysis, test-count verification, line-citation checks, and the repo's own release precedents. I verified these exact code changes in my job `8bffb70b` (including fail-old/pass-new), so the factual basis is already independently established by me. + +--- + +## 1. My independent SemVer determination: **concur β€” `v4.1.3` PATCH, update REQUIRED** + +| Question | My independent verification | +|---|---| +| Are the commits real and as described? | Yes β€” `c49ee3b` (lib.sh +18/-3, h26 test) and `7e15081` (resume scripts +204/-23, t14/t15/t16 tests) match the assessment's Β§2 descriptions exactly; `94f2e21` is docs-only. | +| Update REQUIRED? | Yes β€” `MAM_VERSION="4.1.2"` (lib.sh:32) is now behind the actual code: the shipped framework contains two significant runtime fixes the current version number does not track. | +| MAJOR (v5.0.0)? | No β€” no public surface removed or broken: Class B hard-exit byte-identical, `verify_session.py` zero-diff (both verified by me in `8bffb70b`), no CLI flag/YAML key/adapter changed. | +| MINOR (v4.2.0)? | No β€” no new agent, command, or skill subsystem. The FRESH_SPAWN fallback turns a previously **hard-failing (RC=1) input** into the documented recovery behavior β€” that is the definition of a bug fix (the defect was confirmed by 3 review rounds on the Issue #3 analysis). The only new flag (`--cmd-full` on `update_yaml_resumed.sh`) is internal: that script's sole caller is `resume_session.sh` (verified by grep). Contrast with v4.1.0 (new agent = MINOR): nothing comparable exists here. Repo precedent agrees: v4.1.2's idle-pane-reuse (also a behavior change on a previously-wasteful path) was a PATCH. | +| PATCH (v4.1.3)? | Yes β€” SemVer 2.0.0 Β§6: backward-compatible bug fixes. `455 tests collected` (verified by collect-only) β€” matches the assessment's claim; I ran the full suite green (455/455) in `8bffb70b`. | + +## 2. Assessment document quality β€” accurate with two citation nits + +**Verified correct**: +- Β§2 change descriptions match the actual diffs (I verified both fixes end-to-end in `8bffb70b`, including fail-old/pass-new for t14/t16 and an empirical PGID-detachment experiment). +- Β§3 verdict matrix reasoning is sound and matches my independent derivation above. +- Β§4 lockstep inventory is the right edit surface: lib.sh `MAM_VERSION`, VERSIONS.md header/date/line-15 prose/line-21 prose/8-row matrix/new changelog section, 8Γ— SKILL.md frontmatter, and the `test_version_consistency.py` contract (2/2 passing at 4.1.2 today β€” verified). The VERSIONS.md line numbers cited (9, 10, 15, 21, 23–33, 38) match the current file exactly. +- Β§5 changelog draft is factually accurate: test names (h26/t14/t15/t16), 455 count, Class B preservation (all verified in my prior round), epoch-refinement description matches the `c4b0a075`-challenge fix. +- Constraint honored: the only working-tree change is the assessment document itself; no code/version files touched. + +**Two nits (non-blocking; convergent with Grok's `ec2e02e2` PASS)**: +1. **lib.sh line citation**: Β§4's touchpoint links `lib.sh#L16`, but `MAM_VERSION=` is at **line 32** (the Β§2 spawner citation L207-L224 is correct). One-line fix in the packaging job's checklist. +2. **Missing lockstep item β€” resume SKILL.md body text**: `multi-agent-mux-resume/SKILL.md:55` still says "If both are empty β†’ the workspace has no conversation yet. Fall back to `multi-agent-mux-create`." β€” after `7e15081`, a stopped 0-turn Class A session no longer needs that fallback (resume fresh-spawns it). The assessment's touchpoint list covers the 8 frontmatters but not this body-text sync. Should be added to the v4.1.3 packaging checklist so the docs match the behavior being versioned. + +## 3. Peer verdicts + +- Grok `ec2e02e2`: **PASS** β€” independently reached the same v4.1.3 PATCH determination, with the same two nits (lib.sh line number; resume SKILL.md body). Verified real in the registry. +- Claude `39439652`: running at my report time; not cited as evidence. +- My verdict (this report): **concur v4.1.3 PATCH** β€” 2/3 of the active reviewers so far, from independent chains. + +## 4. Assessment of the "defer the bump" plan + +Correct for this job: the brief explicitly forbids mutating version files now, and deferring the 3-way lockstep to an atomic follow-up packaging job is exactly how v4.1.2 was cut. The changelog draft is ready to paste; only the two nits above should be folded into the packaging checklist. + +--- + +## 5. Verdict + +The assessment is accurate, well-reasoned, and matches my own independent derivation: a version update is **required**, and **`v4.1.3` (PATCH)** is the uniquely correct target under SemVer 2.0.0 Β§6 (no breaking change β†’ not MAJOR; no new feature subsystem β†’ not MINOR; pure backward-compatible bug fixes β†’ PATCH), consistent with the repo's own v4.1.1/v4.1.2 precedents. The lockstep touchpoint inventory is correct and complete for the version surfaces, with two minor non-blocking additions to carry into the packaging job (fix the lib.sh L16β†’L32 citation; add the resume SKILL.md body-text sync). My reviewer opinion for the consensus: **concur with v4.1.3 PATCH**. + +[VERDICT: PASS] \ No newline at end of file