# Cross-review: Issue #3 version-update assessment (`v4.1.3` PATCH)

- **Reviewer**: `reviewer-creator-grok-01`
- **Job**: `ec2e02e2`
- **Target**: `.agents/reports/creator-agy-01/version-update-assessment.md` (job `6c24ddd0`)
- **Method**: independent SemVer read from `git log 0644e77..HEAD`, live `lib.sh`/`VERSIONS.md`/`resume_session.sh`, not the assessment at face value.

---

## Independent SemVer recommendation

**Bump is required. Target: `v4.1.3` (PATCH).** Same conclusion as the assessment.

| Check | Evidence |
|---|---|
| Current release | `0644e77` shipped **`MAM_VERSION="4.1.2"`**. Issue #3 code is **after** that tag (`c49ee3b`, `7e15081`). Shipping those commits still labeled 4.1.2 would misidentify the release. |
| `c49ee3b` | Shim daemon spawn: `nohup&disown` → `Popen(..., start_new_session=True)`. No CLI/YAML/`--agent` change. |
| `7e15081` | Class A empty-UUID resume: RC=1 → `spawn-spec` fallback; optional `--cmd-full`; epoch reset. Class B `verify_session.py:99-101` and `test_t8` untouched. |
| MAJOR §8 | No removed flags, no removed `--agent` values, no YAML key deletions. Class B still hard-exits when truly unresolvable (`test_t15`). |
| MINOR §7 | No new agent/skill/command. Optional `--cmd-full` on `update_yaml_resumed.sh` is an internal helper, additive. Class A success-on-empty-UUID is a **bugfix of a documented recovery hole**, not a new subsystem (unlike `v4.1.0` OpenCode). |
| PATCH §6 | Matches v4.1.1 / v4.1.2 reliability PATCH precedent. |

This reviewer’s vote: **`v4.1.3` PATCH**. Not 4.2.0. Not 5.0.0. Do not leave 4.1.2 on the Issue #3 commits.

## Assessment accuracy

The §3 table (MAJOR/MINOR/PATCH) and §5 changelog draft match the live diffs. Lockstep inventory (8 `SKILL.md` frontmatters, `VERSIONS.md` header + **line 21 prose** + 8-row matrix + new changelog, `test_version_consistency.py`) is the right edit surface. Deferring the actual bump until consensus is correct for this job’s “do not mutate version files” constraint.

## Nits (do not flip the class)

- **`lib.sh` is line 32, not 16.** §4.1 cites `#L16`. Line 16 is header commentary; `MAM_VERSION="4.1.2"` is **line 32**. Packaging must edit 32 (same class of gotcha as VERSIONS.md line-21/24 prose).
- **Resume `SKILL.md` body** still says empty UUID → `multi-agent-mux-create` (line 55). `resume_session.sh` now succeeds for Class A. Add that doc update to the packaging checklist (frontmatter-only lockstep will not catch it).
- Range `0644e77..HEAD` also contains `50a9f32` (v4.1.2 report archive); omitted from the commit list. Harmless.
- **455 tests**: not re-run in this job. Prior Issue #3 targeted run was 20 passed. Do not treat 455 as independently verified here.

No `[ESCALATE: PLANNER]`.

---

[VERDICT: PASS]