🔍 Cross-Review — Markdown Audit & Cleanup Implementation (Job `08e3e7a6`)

Reviewer: planner-reviewer-claude-01
Target: the uncommitted diff implementing plan-e359e7af.md (Rev. 2, refined per creator-agy-01's challenge 9dcd14f6) — 8 modified files, 1 deletion, 1 new archival plan file.
Method: I authored the plan this diff implements, so my focus here is verifying actual execution against the plan's checklist, not re-deriving the findings from scratch — every acceptance-checklist line item was checked directly against the live working tree (not the diff text alone), plus an independent syntax/logic sanity check of the new bash branches and a full regression run.

1. §2 Deletions — verified

mam-agent-creation-fix-report.md (repo root): confirmed removed (ls → No such file). bug-report/mam-agent-creation-fix-report.md confirmed intact (4596 bytes, unchanged).
implementation_plan.md, IMPROVEMENTS.md, MESSAGING.md, AGENTS.md: confirmed zero diff (git diff --stat against these paths returns empty) — correctly left untouched.

2. §3.1/3.3 README + deploy/INSTALL.md content sync — verified

README.md/README.ko.md: both now name all 5 agents in the intro paragraph, the multi-agent-mux-resume bullet, the review-loop bullet, and both Mermaid sequence-diagram Note over R lines. Both add the same v4.1.3 VERSIONS.md-linked badge (not a hardcoded standalone number needing separate lockstep tracking, per the plan's explicit requirement). Both add a one-sentence, accurately-worded note on Herdr daemon process-group isolation (start_new_session=True) matching the real v4.1.3 behavior. Both files' edits are structurally parallel (same insertion points, same content), so language parity holds.
deploy/INSTALL.md:3: confirmed OpenCode added to the parenthetical agent list, single-word diff as specified, no structural change.

3. §3.2 BOOTSTRAP.md/.ko.md — verified, including the Rev. 2 addition

Version badge added identically to both files (same badge markup as README).
8-skill scaffolding list (the Rev. 2 finding): confirmed multi-agent-mux-loop and multi-agent-mux-orc-onboard bullets were added to both language files, in the correct position (end of the skills/ sub-list, same bullet style as the existing 6). I checked the added description text against each skill's own SKILL.md description: frontmatter (not paraphrased from memory) — multi-agent-mux-loop's bullet ("자율적인 계획-실행-교차검증 반복 순환 루프 오케스트레이터" / "Autonomous planning-execution-review loop orchestrator") accurately compresses its real description ("Run an autonomous planning-execution-review loop... until a unanimous PASS is achieved"); multi-agent-mux-orc-onboard's bullet ("오케스트레이터 세션 UUID 온보딩 및 서브에이전트 격리 헬퍼" / "Orchestrator session UUID onboarding and sub-agent isolation helper") accurately compresses its real description ("Register current or specified orchestrator session UUID... to prevent sub-agent discovery capture"). No fabricated capability claims.
Onboarding-section agent-list addition (claude, agy, hermes, grok, opencode) confirmed added identically in both files at the correct location (§7 New Agent Onboarding).

4. §3.7 resume/SKILL.md — verified, including both Rev. 2 additions

Lines 71-75 (the flat if-block → class-aware case): confirmed the echo text now matches resume_session.sh:67's real error string byte-for-byte ("ERROR: No saved session for $WORKSPACE ($AGENT). Use multi-agent-mux-create first."), and the agy|hermes|opencode arm is a no-op (:) with the comment explaining the fresh-spawn fallback, matching the real script's class-based branching described in the plan.
Lines 88-93 (CMD_FULL case): confirmed the new opencode) CMD_FULL="opencode --session $UUID --auto --agent build" ;; arm was added. I independently re-verified this against .agents/skills/lib_py/agents/adapters/opencode.py:188-191's live resume_spec() (f"{binary} --session {session_uuid} --auto --agent build") — exact match, not stale from when the plan checked it.
Line 103 (spawn-dispatch case): confirmed widened from agy|hermes|grok) to agy|hermes|grok|opencode).
Independent logic check beyond the plan's checklist: no test in tests/ parses this markdown file's embedded bash, so I extracted the new branches into a standalone script and ran them directly with AGENT=opencode: bash -n passed (valid syntax), and execution correctly took the fresh-spawn no-op path, built CMD_FULL="opencode --session fake-uuid --auto --agent build", and dispatched into the non-claude spawn branch. No syntax or logic defect in the new arms.

5. §3.8 MULTI_AGENT_RULES.md/.ko.md (Rev. 2 core finding) — verified

Both .agents/MULTI_AGENT_RULES.md:21 and .agents/MULTI_AGENT_RULES.ko.md:21 confirmed changed exactly as specified: cline dropped, grok/opencode added, antigravity/claude/hermes preserved. Diff is scoped to exactly that one line in each file, per the plan's explicit "do not sweep the rest of the file" instruction — confirmed via git diff --stat, 2 lines total changed (1 per file, -1/+1 each).

6. §4/§5 Version lockstep and out-of-scope guards — verified, all held

.agents/skills/lib.sh, VERSIONS.md, nats-docker/: zero diff.
All 8 SKILL.md version: frontmatter lines: git diff -- '.agents/skills/*/SKILL.md' | grep "^[+-]version:" → empty (no touch).
.agents/reports/: only the new (untracked, additive) plan-e359e7af.md archival file — no existing archived report was modified, consistent with "immutable per-job history."
tests/test_version_consistency.py -v: 2 passed (test_three_way_version_lockstep, test_mam_version_is_not_env_overridable).
Full suite (pytest tests/ -q): 455 passed, 0 failed, 11m05s — ran myself, not trusted from any prior claim.

7. Acceptance checklist (from `plan-e359e7af.md` §7) — all items confirmed satisfied

Root duplicate removed, bug-report/ copy intact.
implementation_plan.md/IMPROVEMENTS.md/MESSAGING.md/AGENTS.md byte-identical to pre-job state.
README.md/README.ko.md 5-agent + v4.1.3/Herdr-isolation, parity held.
BOOTSTRAP.md/BOOTSTRAP.ko.md same, plus all 8 skills now listed.
deploy/INSTALL.md:3 names opencode.
resume/SKILL.md 71-75 + 88-93 + 103 all fixed, text verified against real sources.
.agents/MULTI_AGENT_RULES.md/.ko.md:21 updated, scope confined to that line.
lib.sh/VERSIONS.md/8× SKILL.md version fields byte-identical.
Version-consistency tests and full suite 100% pass.
No file under .agents/reports/ modified (only the expected new plan archival file added).

8. Findings

No lint, functional, or omission defects found. Every item specified in the (twice-refined) plan was implemented exactly as specified, cross-checked against live source files rather than trusted from the diff text, and the regression guard (both the targeted lockstep tests and the full suite) is green. The added illustrative bash was further validated by direct execution, beyond what the plan's checklist required. This closes out the full lifecycle of Job e359e7af → challenge 9dcd14f6 → refinement a39a83fb → this implementation.

[VERDICT: PASS]

7.3 KiB Raw Blame History Unescape Escape

🔍 Cross-Review — Markdown Audit & Cleanup Implementation (Job 08e3e7a6)