multi-agent-mux/.agents/reports/canary-projects-multi-agent-mux-creator-claude/report-markdown-analysis-crosscheck.md

Root Markdown Analysis — Cross-Check Report (Creator Claude)

• Reviewer: Creator Claude (canary-projects-multi-agent-mux-creator-claude)
• Date: 2026-07-11
• Brief: .mam/reports/brief-root-markdowns.md
• Cross-checked against: .agents/reports/canary-projects-multi-agent-mux-reviewer-cline/report-markdown-analysis.md (Reviewer Cline, 2026-07-11)
• Method: independent read of all 7 files + git log --follow per file + repo-wide inbound-link grep + verification of implementation claims against shipped commits.

---

Verdict Summary

Cline's verdicts (3 DELETE / 4 KEEP) are confirmed in substance, with one amendment: session_isolation_discussion.md cannot be deleted standalone without breaking two inbound links in live tracked docs (see §6).

#	File	My Verdict	Agrees with Cline?
1	task.md	DELETE	✅
2	implementation_plan.md	DELETE	✅
3	BOOTSTRAP.md	KEEP	✅
4	FUTURE_WORKS.ko.md	KEEP	✅
5	DONE.md	KEEP	✅
6	session_isolation_discussion.md	DELETE — with link cleanup	⚠️ amended
7	AGENTS.md	KEEP	✅

---

Per-File Analysis

1. task.md — DELETE

• Purpose: Developer checklist (Rev.1) for the "deploy URL parameterization" task (MAM_REPO_URL / MAM_ARCHIVE_URL / MAM_INSTALLER_URL).
• Status: The work shipped in commit 6408f4a (2026-07-09, feat(deploy): parameterize distribution URLs via MAM_*_URL env vars) touching exactly the four files the plan prescribed (deploy/install.sh, deploy/update.sh, .env.example, deploy/README.md). Independently verified: all three ${MAM_*_URL:-…} patterns exist at the planned locations (install.sh:57-58, update.sh:139) and both docs carry the variables. Yet every checkbox in the file is still [ ], and the file ends with a stray accidental-paste line (agy --conversation=20cc2d8e-…). Note the file was only ever committed once — bundled into the unrelated isolation-docs commit d76e470.
• Justification: Fully superseded by the shipped commit; retaining an all-unchecked checklist for done work actively misleads future agents. task.md/implementation_plan.md are per-cycle scratch names per .agents/multi_agent_workflow.md — the convention survives deletion of this instance.

2. implementation_plan.md — DELETE

• Purpose: Planner design doc (Rev.1) for the same deploy URL parameterization task; still marked "Draft (사용자 승인 대기)".
• Status: Same as above — implemented byte-for-byte in 6408f4a (default values preserved, .env non-sourcing decision honored, mirror examples added to deploy/README.md:35-40).
• Justification: Superseded by shipped code. The only inbound link is from task.md, which is deleted in the same set. Design rationale worth preserving is already encoded in the commit message, .env.example comments, and deploy/README.md.

3. BOOTSTRAP.md — KEEP

• Purpose: Agent-facing setup/verification guide (env config, venv, MQTT handshake test).
• Status: Active. Referenced from README.md:177,186, and explicitly in the deploy installer's runtime-doc allowlist (deploy/install.sh:131 copies MESSAGING.md BOOTSTRAP.md BOOTSTRAP.ko.md AGENTS.md) — deleting it would silently degrade every fresh install. Last substantively updated 2026-07-09.
• Justification: Load-bearing runtime asset, not a dev leftover. (Same verdict extends to BOOTSTRAP.ko.md.)

4. FUTURE_WORKS.ko.md — KEEP

• Purpose: Korean roadmap of pending improvements (FW-P1P7, FW-W1W7, FW-D2~D4 open; FW-D1 resolved).
• Status: Active backlog — most items remain unimplemented (e.g., FW-P6 root-marker detection, FW-P7 monitor HMAC hardening). Maintained mirror of FUTURE_WORKS.md.
• Justification: This is the project's only backlog tracker; deletion loses planned work. (Same verdict for the English FUTURE_WORKS.md.)

5. DONE.md — KEEP

• Purpose: Verified completion record for 28 items (FW-01FW-16, FW-L1L3, FW-N1~N7, FW-W3) with per-item commits and 3-agent cross-verification results.
• Status: Static historical record; explicitly linked from FUTURE_WORKS.md:4 ("For completed items, see DONE.md") and its Korean twin.
• Justification: Deleting it dangles the FUTURE_WORKS reference and erases the audit trail mapping FW-IDs to commits. Zero maintenance cost. (Same for DONE.ko.md.)

6. session_isolation_discussion.md — DELETE, but only with link cleanup (amendment to Cline)

• Purpose: Rev.3 consolidated design discussion for the session-ID isolation feature.
• Status: Superseded — the doc itself declares implementation_plan.session_isolation.md (Rev.3) the single source of truth, and the feature is fully implemented, integration-tested, and PASSed by both reviewers (commits through dad99f5).
• Amendment: Cline's report misses that two live tracked docs still link to it: implementation_plan.session_isolation.md:6 (관련 자료) and task.session_isolation.md:3 (기준 문서). Standalone deletion creates dangling links.
• Recommendation: Treat the whole isolation doc set (session_isolation_discussion.md, Problem_Definition.md, implementation_plan.session_isolation.md, task.session_isolation.md, session_isolation_handover.md — the latter four out of this brief's scope) as one unit: either delete/archive them together (the feature is done and PASSed; the durable outcome lives in .agents/reports/*/report-isolation-review.md and git history), or if only the discussion doc goes now, remove the two inbound link references in the same commit.

7. AGENTS.md — KEEP

• Purpose: Core behavioral guidelines for all agents; entry pointer to .agents/MULTI_AGENT_RULES.md.
• Status: Active and essential — copied to target projects by both installers (scripts/install_mam.sh:127,138 and deploy/install.sh:131), referenced by README and the orchestration rules.
• Justification: Deleting it breaks both install paths and the documented onboarding flow.

---

Out-of-Scope Observations (for the record)

1. The root holds 18 markdown files; the brief covered 7. The undiscussed siblings share the fates above: *.ko.md twins follow their English counterparts; the four other session-isolation docs should be dispositioned as a set with #6.
2. The uncommitted working-tree .gitignore change adding .agents/reports (flagged in my installer verdict) is still present and would ignore the very reports directory this brief writes into — it should be resolved before committing any deletions.
3. Deletions of tracked files require git rm + commit; per standing constraints I have not deleted or committed anything — this report is analysis only.

Final Verdict

PASS on Cline's analysis with the §6 amendment: 3 DELETE / 4 KEEP confirmed; session_isolation_discussion.md must be deleted together with cleanup of its two inbound links (or as part of archiving the whole isolation doc set).