Godopu
f57cd5cdde
- Delete adapters/cline.py and unregister from registry.py - Remove cline branches from lib.sh and all 8 skill scripts (create, resume, stop, status, reconcile, update_yaml_resumed, resolve_session_id, orc_onboard) - Narrow own-key mapping dictionaries across lib_py core modules to 4 supported agents - Delete cline-exclusive tests and retarget shared fixtures to grok/hermes/claude - Update skills documentation and installation guides (439 passed, 0 failures) - Archive cline deprecation consensus and review reports
1.6 KiB
1.6 KiB
Re-review: cline_deprecation_opinion.md (Rev.3)
- Reviewer:
reviewer-creator-grok-01 - Job:
d1fe1a99(follow-up to0a056794[VERDICT: NOT PASS]) - Artifact:
.agents/reports/cline_deprecation_opinion.md(untracked; no skill/framework code in the diff)
Prior blocking items
| ID | Rev.2 defect | Rev.3 |
|---|---|---|
| F1 | Claimed no --api-key-override exists |
Fixed. §3.2 and §6.2 cite -k, --key <api-key> as spawn/run-start injection, bound as not mid-task refresh / not modal suppression. --headless/--non-interactive absence still holds against live cline --help. |
| F2 | Claimed claude drift-C has sibling_claimed |
Fixed. §2.3 / §6.1: only agy (~692) and hermes (~742); claude (~637) and cline (~785) both lack it. |
| F3 | “All three independently demand a drift-C fix either way” | Fixed. Hermes: condition of RETAIN. Planner: urgent if RETAIN. Grok: delete the block if REMOVE. |
Remainder (non-blocking)
- Honest 2–1 split preserved. Grok REMOVE in §1/§4 is accurate (no assignable UUID; unattended/modal gap; no live cline session).
- §5 blast-radius constraints still match
e0916903(keep_pane_quiescent/ paste-normalize; retargettest_c1_*; no drive-bycline.pydelete). - §2 heading still says “fully agree” while point 3 now states a disposition split. Content is honest; heading is slightly loose. Not worth another loop.
- Grok’s REMOVE vote is unchanged. This PASS is on the synthesis, not a vote flip.
No [ESCALATE: PLANNER]. GM still owns REMOVE vs conditional-RETAIN.
[VERDICT: PASS]