multi-agent-mux/.agents/reports/planner-reviewer-claude-01/report-150a6d9a.md

🔍 Cross-Review — v4.1.0 Version Bump Execution (Job 150a6d9a)

• Reviewer: planner-reviewer-claude-01
• Target: The actual 3-way version-lockstep bump execution — .agents/skills/lib.sh:32, VERSIONS.md (header/line-24 prose/8-row matrix/changelog), and 8× SKILL.md frontmatters — plus carry-forward files already reviewed in prior rounds: the Rev.2 version_upgrade_recommendation.md, three newly-promoted durable review reports (report-b087ad92.md, report-250399e4.md, report-80e891c1.md), and docs/OPENCODE_OLLAMA_GUIDE.md.
• Method: independently re-verified every file on disk (not the diff text) against the brief's four explicit requirements, ran the lockstep test and the full suite myself, and spot-checked that the newly-added report files are unmodified copies of their source job outputs rather than trusting the promotion claim.

---

1. Requirement 1 — MAM_VERSION in lib.sh:32

$ grep -n "MAM_VERSION=" .agents/skills/lib.sh
32:MAM_VERSION="4.1.0"

Correct. Single source of truth updated.

2. Requirement 2 — VERSIONS.md

All four sub-items independently confirmed on the live file (not the diff):

• Header: **프레임워크 버전**: \v4.1.0`with최신 릴리스 일시: 2026-08-29 (KST)` — correct version and date.
• Line 24 prose (the exact desync this session's earlier ec388212/Rev.2 rounds flagged as not covered by the lockstep test's regex, and therefore easy to miss by a literal-minded bump): "모든 8개 스킬은 ... \v4.1.0`으로 동기화되어 배포됩니다."` — updated correctly, this time on the first pass.
• 8-row skill matrix: grep -n '| \4.1.0` |' returns all 8 rows (create, stop, resume, status, monitor, delegate-job, loop, orc-onboard); no 4.0.0` cell remains.
• Changelog section: ### 🚀 \v4.1.0` — OpenCode AI Agent Integration (2026-08-29)is present, positioned correctly above thev4.0.0section, and its F-1/F-2/F-3 content (adapter implementation, 29-touchpoint CLI wiring,OPENCODE_PERMISSION empty-guard, test suite expansion) accurately reflects what this session already independently verified in the code-review rounds (a65aaf9f→b6fd3987→3473d7e3→b3aa4b6f`) — no new unverified claims introduced here.

3. Requirement 3 — 8× SKILL.md frontmatter

$ grep -rn "^version:" .agents/skills/multi-agent-mux-{create,stop,resume,status,monitor,delegate-job,loop,orc-onboard}/SKILL.md

All 8 read version: 4.1.0. git diff --stat on these 8 files confirms each is a clean 1-line diff (2 +-) — no incidental content drift alongside the version bump.

4. Requirement 4 — Verification

• pytest tests/test_version_consistency.py -q → 2 passed (I ran this myself, not reused from a cited report).
• pytest tests/ -q (full suite, run myself in the background for this job) → 447 passed in 788.39s (0:13:08), exit clean. Same count as every prior round in this session; zero regressions from the doc/version-only changes.

5. Carry-Forward Files (already independently reviewed by three real reviewers; spot-verified here, not re-litigated)

• version_upgrade_recommendation.md (Rev.2): I already gave this [VERDICT: PASS] in job b087ad92. Since then, two more independent reviewers reached the same conclusion on the identical content: Grok (job 250399e4, PASS) and OpenCode (job 80e891c1, PASS) — both real, registry-verifiable (.mam/jobs/250399e4, .mam/jobs/80e891c1 exist with genuine briefs/reports). This is now a real, triple-independently-verified 3/3 consensus — the exact opposite of the fabricated 4/4 table that started this review chain, and worth noting as the correct outcome the process was supposed to produce.
• Promoted report files — checked for tampering via direct diff against each source job artifact rather than trusting the promotion:

  $ diff .agents/reports/planner-reviewer-claude-01/report-b087ad92.md .mam/jobs/b087ad92/claude-reports/report-final.md   # exit 0
  $ diff .agents/reports/reviewer-creator-grok-01/report-250399e4.md .mam/jobs/250399e4/grok-reports/report-final.md      # exit 0
  $ diff .agents/reports/reviewer-opencode-01/report-80e891c1.md .mam/jobs/80e891c1/opencode-reports/report-final.md      # exit 0
  

  All three are byte-identical to their originals. No selective editing when promoting to the durable path.
• docs/OPENCODE_OLLAMA_GUIDE.md: already checked in job b087ad92 — its MAM-integration example flags (--workspace, --agent, --role, --session, --herdr-session, --herdr-workspace, --onboard) were verified against the real create_session.sh/resume_session.sh parsers and found accurate; unchanged since. Remains out-of-scope-but-harmless for the SemVer/version-bump question, consistent with both Grok's and OpenCode's "residual nit — do not fold into changelog unless asked" note (correctly, it was not folded into the v4.1.0 changelog entry).

6. Working-Tree Hygiene

git status --short shows exactly the 10 files the brief's requirements touch (lib.sh, 8× SKILL.md, VERSIONS.md) plus the already-reviewed doc carry-forwards — nothing unexpected, no stray edits, HEAD still at de2c0e6 (bump correctly staged as working-tree changes, not yet committed — matches the brief's scope of "bump the files," with the release-commit step left for a separate, later action per the recommendation doc's own §5 checklist).

---

7. Verdict

All four brief requirements are met and independently re-verified from the live files, not from the diff text or worker claims: MAM_VERSION updated, VERSIONS.md's all four sub-parts (header, line-24 prose, matrix, changelog) updated correctly including the previously-error-prone line-24 gotcha, all 8 SKILL.md frontmatters updated with zero incidental drift, lockstep test passes (2/2), and the full suite passes (447/447, self-run). The carry-forward documentation files are unmodified since their own independently-verified PASS rounds, now backed by a genuine 3/3 cross-agent consensus (Claude/Grok/OpenCode) rather than the fabricated one this review chain started with. No lint, functionality, or omission defects found. No design rework needed.

[VERDICT: PASS]