Files

T

Godopu 94f2e213d2 docs(reports): archive Issue #3 analysis, implementation plan, and multi-agent peer review reports

- Add Rev. 3 technical analysis report from creator-agy-01
- Add implementation plan from planner-reviewer-claude-01
- Add peer review reports across analysis and implementation review loops (Claude, Grok, OpenCode)

2026-08-31 10:30:46 +09:00

2.2 KiB

Raw Blame History

Re-adjudication: Issue #3 analysis Rev. 3 (Class B reversal)

Reviewer: reviewer-creator-grok-01
Job: 1da8fd5c
Target: .agents/reports/creator-agy-01/issue-3-analysis.md (Rev. 3, job 6b391a80)
Prior: 1a4f5236 NOT PASS (mechanism); 9075a39f PASS on Rev. 2. Rev. 3 retracts Class B as a defect.
Method: read verify_session.py:99-101 and claude.py::resume_spec; ran pytest tests/test_uuid_target.py myself. Did not take the Class B reversal at face value.

Class B — `[ADJUDICATION: SUSTAINED]`

1a4f5236 claimed assigned claude/grok ids fail verify_session_uuid(..., mode="revalidate") when no transcript exists. That skipped an early return that is live in source:

    if (mode == "revalidate" and row.get("session_id_source") == "assigned"
            and not row.get("session_id_verified")):
        return True

stop_session.sh never writes session_id_source / session_id_verified, so a 0-turn stop keeps assigned + verified=false. find_workspace_uuid therefore emits the YAML own-key. resume_spec for claude uses --session-id when materialized is false (claude.py:99-100).

Independent run: pytest tests/test_uuid_target.py → 13 passed in 114.74s (includes test_t8_resume_unmaterialized_assigned_id). Class B 0-turn resume is working as designed. Rev. 3 is right to mark it NOT A DEFECT. §4 correctly says do not touch this hatch.

Item 1 and Class A — still confirmed

Unchanged from 9075a39f / live code:

Item 1: nohup+disown at lib.sh:211-213; non-interactive & keeps the shim PGID; SIGHUP handled, SIGTERM/SIGINT to the group are not. Portable Popen(..., start_new_session=True) remains the right later fix.
Class A: agy/hermes/opencode own-key stays empty; resume_session.sh:54-57 hard-exits; create still requires --role. Automation recovery gap stands. Scope later work to Class A only.

Residual nit

Rev. 3 says tests/test_uuid_target.py is 12/12. This run collected 13 tests, all passing. Does not change the Class B conclusion.

No [ESCALATE: PLANNER]. Analysis-only; planning can proceed on Item 1 + Class A.

[VERDICT: PASS]

2.2 KiB Raw Blame History

Re-adjudication: Issue #3 analysis Rev. 3 (Class B reversal)

Class B — [ADJUDICATION: SUSTAINED]

Item 1 and Class A — still confirmed

Residual nit

2.2 KiB

Raw Blame History

Class B — `[ADJUDICATION: SUSTAINED]`