Files
multi-agent-mux/.agents/reports/reviewer-creator-grok-01/report-c4f0ffc7.md
T

1.7 KiB

Issue #5 Phase 1 review (265a1f6..6ad6f08, HEAD)

  • Reviewer: reviewer-creator-grok-01
  • Job: c4f0ffc7
  • HEAD: 6ad6f08 (docs residuals) on top of 95f3e9a (R1/R2/F-1)
  • Tests this turn: pytest tests/test_issue5_phase1_delegation.py tests/test_version_consistency.py → 68 passed. git diff --check fc0bd96..HEAD clean.

Code (R1 / R2 / F-1 / O-1)

Already sustained in job 8d4e0e0e. Re-checked on HEAD:

  • R1: _delegation_py (lib.sh:1960-1967) uses python -c + sys.path.insert(0, SKILL_DIR), not -m. cwd unchanged. test_r1_* still in the 68.
  • R2: _fingerprint is the full BrokerConfig field set; mismatch names fields, not values.
  • F-1: _send maps only MQTT_ERR_NO_CONN → ConnectionError; retry tuple unchanged. FakeInfo.rc matches paho.
  • O-1: _publish_once → OneShotPublisher.publish_raw.

Loop still submits via delegate_job_safe (wrapper), not _delegation_py. Auto-complete: run_loop.sh untouched in this fix series.


Residuals from Round 2 — closed or parked

Item Status
Benchmark fork table still said -m Closed in 6ad6f08. Table names _delegation_py → python -c + insert; note explains why -m was dropped.
Freeze _delegate_py_bin walks to system python (no paho) Parked on P3-02 (task.md:94). Accurate: freeze dir has no .venv; Phase 1 production path is the wrapper, not frozen helpers. Must fix when Phase 3 calls those helpers from freeze lib.sh.

Round 1 Grok error

PYTHONPATH=$SKILL_DIR + python -m is not B-13. -m puts cwd first. R1 fix is the real guarantee.

[ADJUDICATION: SUSTAINED] on R1/R2/F-1.

No [ESCALATE: PLANNER].


[VERDICT: PASS]