multi-agent-mux/.agents/reports/planner-reviewer-claude-01/report-c961d453.md

📋 Review Report: Implementation Verification (Job c961d453)

• Reviewer: planner-reviewer-claude-01
• Job ID: c961d453
• Role: Reviewer
• Target: Review of creator-grok-01 Implementation (Job bd464770)

---

1. Code Review & Verification Findings

1. run_loop.sh:

   • --creator properly assigned to TARGET_AGENT.
   • --target-agent explicitly triggers the removal error with exit code 1.
   • --planner properly captures session override and requires --plan in pre-freeze checks.
   • Post-freeze bypasses resolve_planner_session() when explicit --planner is provided, performing correct 2-branch validation (not registered vs not running).
   • usage() is fully updated and clear.

2. In-Repo References:

   • loop_delegation_guard.sh, SKILL.md, deploy/INSTALL.md, and existing test files (test_o3, test_o2, test_tier4) all correctly migrated to --creator.

3. Test Suite:

   • New tests/test_loop_cli.py covers all 9 test cases with 100% PASS.

[VERDICT: PASS]