docs(reports): archive v4.1.3 version update assessment and unanimous peer review reports

2026-08-31 11:25:09 +09:00
parent 85a46ef98b
commit 4b2f703a73
4 changed files with 269 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
+# 🔍 Cross-Review + Independent Reviewer Opinion: Version Update Assessment for Issue #3 Commits (Job 71a1b000)
+
+- **Reviewer**: `reviewer-opencode-01` (role: reviewer) — this report serves both as a cross-review of the assessment document and as my independent reviewer opinion for the requested consensus.
+- **Target**: `.agents/reports/creator-agy-01/version-update-assessment.md` (job `6c24ddd0`, `creator-agy-01`) — assessment-only deliverable (no code/version-file mutations permitted), evaluating commits `c49ee3b` + `7e15081` (+ docs `94f2e21`) for version-bump necessity and target version.
+- **Method**: Every claim re-verified from live source and my own runs — commit contents, public-surface diff analysis, test-count verification, line-citation checks, and the repo's own release precedents. I verified these exact code changes in my job `8bffb70b` (including fail-old/pass-new), so the factual basis is already independently established by me.
+
+---
+
+## 1. My independent SemVer determination: **concur — `v4.1.3` PATCH, update REQUIRED**
+
+| Question | My independent verification |
+|---|---|
+| Are the commits real and as described? | Yes — `c49ee3b` (lib.sh +18/-3, h26 test) and `7e15081` (resume scripts +204/-23, t14/t15/t16 tests) match the assessment's §2 descriptions exactly; `94f2e21` is docs-only. |
+| Update REQUIRED? | Yes — `MAM_VERSION="4.1.2"` (lib.sh:32) is now behind the actual code: the shipped framework contains two significant runtime fixes the current version number does not track. |
+| MAJOR (v5.0.0)? | No — no public surface removed or broken: Class B hard-exit byte-identical, `verify_session.py` zero-diff (both verified by me in `8bffb70b`), no CLI flag/YAML key/adapter changed. |
+| MINOR (v4.2.0)? | No — no new agent, command, or skill subsystem. The FRESH_SPAWN fallback turns a previously **hard-failing (RC=1) input** into the documented recovery behavior — that is the definition of a bug fix (the defect was confirmed by 3 review rounds on the Issue #3 analysis). The only new flag (`--cmd-full` on `update_yaml_resumed.sh`) is internal: that script's sole caller is `resume_session.sh` (verified by grep). Contrast with v4.1.0 (new agent = MINOR): nothing comparable exists here. Repo precedent agrees: v4.1.2's idle-pane-reuse (also a behavior change on a previously-wasteful path) was a PATCH. |
+| PATCH (v4.1.3)? | Yes — SemVer 2.0.0 §6: backward-compatible bug fixes. `455 tests collected` (verified by collect-only) — matches the assessment's claim; I ran the full suite green (455/455) in `8bffb70b`. |
+
+## 2. Assessment document quality — accurate with two citation nits
+
+**Verified correct**:
+- §2 change descriptions match the actual diffs (I verified both fixes end-to-end in `8bffb70b`, including fail-old/pass-new for t14/t16 and an empirical PGID-detachment experiment).
+- §3 verdict matrix reasoning is sound and matches my independent derivation above.
+- §4 lockstep inventory is the right edit surface: lib.sh `MAM_VERSION`, VERSIONS.md header/date/line-15 prose/line-21 prose/8-row matrix/new changelog section, 8× SKILL.md frontmatter, and the `test_version_consistency.py` contract (2/2 passing at 4.1.2 today — verified). The VERSIONS.md line numbers cited (9, 10, 15, 21, 23–33, 38) match the current file exactly.
+- §5 changelog draft is factually accurate: test names (h26/t14/t15/t16), 455 count, Class B preservation (all verified in my prior round), epoch-refinement description matches the `c4b0a075`-challenge fix.
+- Constraint honored: the only working-tree change is the assessment document itself; no code/version files touched.
+
+**Two nits (non-blocking; convergent with Grok's `ec2e02e2` PASS)**:
+1. **lib.sh line citation**: §4's touchpoint links `lib.sh#L16`, but `MAM_VERSION=` is at **line 32** (the §2 spawner citation L207-L224 is correct). One-line fix in the packaging job's checklist.
+2. **Missing lockstep item — resume SKILL.md body text**: `multi-agent-mux-resume/SKILL.md:55` still says "If both are empty → the workspace has no conversation yet. Fall back to `multi-agent-mux-create`." — after `7e15081`, a stopped 0-turn Class A session no longer needs that fallback (resume fresh-spawns it). The assessment's touchpoint list covers the 8 frontmatters but not this body-text sync. Should be added to the v4.1.3 packaging checklist so the docs match the behavior being versioned.
+
+## 3. Peer verdicts
+
+- Grok `ec2e02e2`: **PASS** — independently reached the same v4.1.3 PATCH determination, with the same two nits (lib.sh line number; resume SKILL.md body). Verified real in the registry.
+- Claude `39439652`: running at my report time; not cited as evidence.
+- My verdict (this report): **concur v4.1.3 PATCH** — 2/3 of the active reviewers so far, from independent chains.
+
+## 4. Assessment of the "defer the bump" plan
+
+Correct for this job: the brief explicitly forbids mutating version files now, and deferring the 3-way lockstep to an atomic follow-up packaging job is exactly how v4.1.2 was cut. The changelog draft is ready to paste; only the two nits above should be folded into the packaging checklist.
+
+---
+
+## 5. Verdict
+
+The assessment is accurate, well-reasoned, and matches my own independent derivation: a version update is **required**, and **`v4.1.3` (PATCH)** is the uniquely correct target under SemVer 2.0.0 §6 (no breaking change → not MAJOR; no new feature subsystem → not MINOR; pure backward-compatible bug fixes → PATCH), consistent with the repo's own v4.1.1/v4.1.2 precedents. The lockstep touchpoint inventory is correct and complete for the version surfaces, with two minor non-blocking additions to carry into the packaging job (fix the lib.sh L16→L32 citation; add the resume SKILL.md body-text sync). My reviewer opinion for the consensus: **concur with v4.1.3 PATCH**.
+
+[VERDICT: PASS]