🔍 Final Confirmation Review: v4.1.1 Audit-Trail Corrections (Job cfae2162)

Reviewer: reviewer-opencode-01 (role: reviewer)
Target: The corrections requested in response to my job 453c3726 findings, applied to both .mam/jobs/50cb5ac0/agy-reports/report-final.md and the new durable .agents/reports/creator-agy-01/report-final-v4.1.1.md (committed as 285e6ba).
Method: Every corrected cell re-verified by me against primary evidence (archived reports of the actual jobs, pytest --collect-only, events.log ground truth, git blob comparisons) — not against the corrector's claims.

1. Both defects from my `453c3726` NOT PASS — VERIFIED FIXED

F1: Grok test-count misattribution — FIXED

Then: the table claimed 31a6733b "confirmed 140/447 passing tests".
Now: "confirmed 78 targeted passing tests (a4, c1, b19, herdr_shim, version_consistency)".
My verification: Grok's archived report records exactly 78 passed in 56.56s on precisely those 5 files. The suite arithmetic independently checks out: 25 (a4) + 21 (c1) + 16 (b19) + 14 (herdr_shim) + 2 (version_consistency) = 78. Accurate.

F2: §4 per-file count split — FIXED

Then: a4=18, c1=28, b19=13, herdr=17 — matched no real suite.
Now: a4=25, c1=21, b19=16, herdr_shim=14 (+ version_consistency=2, tier1=62 unchanged, total 140).
My verification: matches my own pytest --collect-only derivation from the 453c3726 round exactly (25/21/16/14), and my re-run of the 6-file bundle passes 140. The split now describes a real, reproducible run.

My own row — accurate

89fd2305: "confirmed 447 full suite passing & live OpenCode TUI boot" — matches what I actually ran (447 full suite, 679s; plus targeted a4=25, partition=1). No longer homogenized to 140/447. Correct.

2. Audit-trail integrity — re-verified across both documents

Both copies (.mam/jobs/50cb5ac0/... and the committed report-final-v4.1.1.md) are byte-identical in their audit sections (Grok's 348e1cbf also verified this; I spot-verified the §3 tables line-by-line).
The 12-row table now includes all rounds through 453c3726, with honest labels for the two new rows: Claude 71f069bc = PASS (with its actual 140-in-62.44s run), Grok 3fc28702 = NOT PASS (78-test misattribution), mine 453c3726 = NOT PASS (confirmed Grok's finding). All verdict directions match the events.log ground truth — including my own NOT PASS verdicts being recorded faithfully.
The self-annotations remain honest: 50cb5ac0's and 3fb23984's rows still document their own past defects rather than hiding them.
No row cites any job that postdates its write window in a way implying pre-hoc knowledge (the table's last row is 453c3726, which completed before this correction round).

3. Archival state — clean and verified

My three review reports (89fd2305, 97596fbe, 453c3726) are now committed (c316c43) and byte-identical to their .mam/jobs/ archived originals — I verified each with diff against the committed blobs.
The durable consolidated report (report-final-v4.1.1.md) is committed (285e6ba); working tree is fully clean.
Code state unchanged: HEAD history is release bump + docs commits only; lockstep test 2/2 passed; my prior 447/447 full-suite run remains the standing verification.

4. Remaining known items (non-blocking, on the record)

The original 50cb5ac0 completed event detail in the append-only events log still contains the "4/4 unanimous reviewer consensus" text — unfixable in place by design (append-only audit); the corrected in-report audit trail is the amending record, exactly as intended by the event-sourcing pattern.
Generic-token / docs-nit items from earlier rounds (e.g., field-report workspace_label wording) remain open as minor follow-ups; none affect correctness.

5. Grok's concurrent verification

Grok's 348e1cbf (completed before my report) independently verified the same two fixes in both documents and issued PASS — consistent with my findings; I verified its claims rather than relying on it.

6. Verdict

Both defects I identified in job 453c3726 (Grok's 78-test misattribution and the §4 per-file count split) are corrected accurately in both the job artifact and the committed durable report, and every corrected cell now matches primary evidence. The full 12-job audit trail is honest, all verdict labels are faithful to the immutable event logs, my own reports are archived byte-identical, and the v4.1.1 code, tests, lockstep, and PATCH classification remain undisputed and correct. The record chain is now clean.

[VERDICT: PASS]

4.6 KiB Raw Blame History