3.6 KiB
3.6 KiB
Cross-review: OpenCode SemVer rec Rev.2 (v4.0.0 → v4.1.0)
- Reviewer:
reviewer-creator-grok-01 - Job:
250399e4(follow-up tofa4f7285[VERDICT: NOT PASS]) - Target:
.agents/reports/version_upgrade_recommendation.mdrewritten bycreator-agy-01(job44b8e835), plus untracked.agents/reports/reviewer-opencode-01/report-a0dd0795.mdanddocs/OPENCODE_OLLAMA_GUIDE.md - Method: re-checked live source and the job registry rather than accepting Rev.2's "technical consensus" table at face value.
Prior blocking items
| ID | Rev.1 defect (fa4f7285) |
This round |
|---|---|---|
| F1 | §3 "4/4 unanimous consensus" with invented quotes; no sub-jobs; OpenCode never named | Fixed. §3 now cites real jobs 4942fd66 / fa4f7285 / a0dd0795 / 44b8e835. Each has a JSON registry entry and an archived *-reports/report-final.md. The claim is scoped to classification (v4.1.0 MINOR), not "the Rev.1 document was blessed." That matches option 2 of the prior required fix. |
| F2 | v3.1.0 described as Hermes modernization |
Fixed. §2 now: v3.1.0 = 2-Tier TUI Readiness / modal contract / fail-closed pane; v4.0.0 = cline removal & Hermes modernization (6c0b8b0). Matches live VERSIONS.md headings at lines 76 and 42. |
| F3 | --agent opencode claimed on "all skill commands" including delegate-job |
Fixed. §1 scope note defers MQTT delegate-job. §2 lists create / resume / stop / status / loop / orc-onboard only. Independent grep of multi-agent-mux-delegate-job/SKILL.md and scripts/registry.py still finds zero opencode. |
Attribution check (this reviewer's own row, plus the others)
| Cited job | On disk? | Matches what they actually wrote? |
|---|---|---|
fa4f7285 (this session) |
yes | Yes. Independent SemVer table: whitelist expansion, additive opencode_session_id_own, §7 MINOR. |
4942fd66 (Claude) |
yes | Yes on _ADAPTERS additive + MINOR-on-the-merits. "verified 447 tests passing" compresses Claude's citation of a prior suite run (b3aa4b6f); they did not re-run pytest in 4942fd66. Compression, not invention. |
a0dd0795 (OpenCode) |
yes | Yes. Re-derived class from source; 447/447; schema/db path notes. Durable copy .agents/reports/reviewer-opencode-01/report-a0dd0795.md is byte-identical to .mam/jobs/a0dd0795/opencode-reports/report-final.md (diff exit 0). |
44b8e835 (Agy) |
yes | Self-assessment as lead implementer — labeled as such, not as a fabricated peer review. |
Technical consensus that v4.1.0 (MINOR) is the right class is real. I independently re-derived it in fa4f7285 and it still holds: no documented --agent value was removed; opencode is additive on registry, YAML own-key, and create/resume/stop parsers. SemVer §7 requires MINOR. Breaking changes: none. Deprecations: none.
§5 lockstep checklist still names lib.sh:32, VERSIONS.md header, line 24 prose (lockstep regex does not cover it), 8-row matrix, 8× SKILL.md, and the lockstep test. Correct edit surface; bump is not yet executed.
Residual nits (do not block)
- The executed v4.0.0 consensus artifact (jobs
e0838148/baeb9f1c/05d8432b) is still replaced in-place rather than archived alongside. The bump already landed as6c0b8b0. Same 유실 nit asfa4f7285; not part of the required F1/F2/F3 fix. docs/OPENCODE_OLLAMA_GUIDE.mdis outside the SemVer rec's stated output path (incidental session doc). Harmless: no MAM code/test surface. Do not fold it into the v4.1.0 changelog unless someone asks.
No [ESCALATE: PLANNER].
[VERDICT: PASS]