Godopu
9b831932b0
- Delete task.md / implementation_plan.md (deploy URL parameterization shipped in 6408f4a; checklists were stale) and session_isolation_discussion.md (superseded by implementation_plan.session_isolation.md; feature shipped and PASSed) - Remove the two inbound links to the deleted discussion doc - Add reviewer analysis reports and this cleanup plan under .agents/reports/
76 lines
7.0 KiB
Markdown
76 lines
7.0 KiB
Markdown
# Root Markdown Analysis — Cross-Check Report (Creator Claude)
|
|
|
|
- **Reviewer**: Creator Claude (`canary-projects-multi-agent-mux-creator-claude`)
|
|
- **Date**: 2026-07-11
|
|
- **Brief**: `.mam/reports/brief-root-markdowns.md`
|
|
- **Cross-checked against**: `.agents/reports/canary-projects-multi-agent-mux-reviewer-cline/report-markdown-analysis.md` (Reviewer Cline, 2026-07-11)
|
|
- **Method**: independent read of all 7 files + `git log --follow` per file + repo-wide inbound-link grep + verification of implementation claims against shipped commits.
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Verdict Summary
|
|
|
|
Cline's verdicts (3 DELETE / 4 KEEP) are **confirmed in substance**, with **one amendment**: `session_isolation_discussion.md` cannot be deleted standalone without breaking two inbound links in live tracked docs (see §6).
|
|
|
|
| # | File | My Verdict | Agrees with Cline? |
|
|
|---|------|-----------|--------------------|
|
|
| 1 | `task.md` | **DELETE** | ✅ |
|
|
| 2 | `implementation_plan.md` | **DELETE** | ✅ |
|
|
| 3 | `BOOTSTRAP.md` | **KEEP** | ✅ |
|
|
| 4 | `FUTURE_WORKS.ko.md` | **KEEP** | ✅ |
|
|
| 5 | `DONE.md` | **KEEP** | ✅ |
|
|
| 6 | `session_isolation_discussion.md` | **DELETE — with link cleanup** | ⚠️ amended |
|
|
| 7 | `AGENTS.md` | **KEEP** | ✅ |
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Per-File Analysis
|
|
|
|
### 1. `task.md` — DELETE
|
|
- **Purpose**: Developer checklist (Rev.1) for the "deploy URL parameterization" task (`MAM_REPO_URL` / `MAM_ARCHIVE_URL` / `MAM_INSTALLER_URL`).
|
|
- **Status**: The work **shipped in commit `6408f4a`** (2026-07-09, `feat(deploy): parameterize distribution URLs via MAM_*_URL env vars`) touching exactly the four files the plan prescribed (`deploy/install.sh`, `deploy/update.sh`, `.env.example`, `deploy/README.md`). Independently verified: all three `${MAM_*_URL:-…}` patterns exist at the planned locations (`install.sh:57-58`, `update.sh:139`) and both docs carry the variables. Yet every checkbox in the file is still `[ ]`, and the file ends with a stray accidental-paste line (`agy --conversation=20cc2d8e-…`). Note the file was only ever committed once — bundled into the unrelated isolation-docs commit `d76e470`.
|
|
- **Justification**: Fully superseded by the shipped commit; retaining an all-unchecked checklist for done work actively misleads future agents. `task.md`/`implementation_plan.md` are per-cycle scratch names per `.agents/multi_agent_workflow.md` — the *convention* survives deletion of this instance.
|
|
|
|
### 2. `implementation_plan.md` — DELETE
|
|
- **Purpose**: Planner design doc (Rev.1) for the same deploy URL parameterization task; still marked "Draft (사용자 승인 대기)".
|
|
- **Status**: Same as above — implemented byte-for-byte in `6408f4a` (default values preserved, `.env` non-sourcing decision honored, mirror examples added to `deploy/README.md:35-40`).
|
|
- **Justification**: Superseded by shipped code. The only inbound link is from `task.md`, which is deleted in the same set. Design rationale worth preserving is already encoded in the commit message, `.env.example` comments, and `deploy/README.md`.
|
|
|
|
### 3. `BOOTSTRAP.md` — KEEP
|
|
- **Purpose**: Agent-facing setup/verification guide (env config, venv, MQTT handshake test).
|
|
- **Status**: Active. Referenced from `README.md:177,186`, and explicitly in the deploy installer's runtime-doc **allowlist** (`deploy/install.sh:131` copies `MESSAGING.md BOOTSTRAP.md BOOTSTRAP.ko.md AGENTS.md`) — deleting it would silently degrade every fresh install. Last substantively updated 2026-07-09.
|
|
- **Justification**: Load-bearing runtime asset, not a dev leftover. (Same verdict extends to `BOOTSTRAP.ko.md`.)
|
|
|
|
### 4. `FUTURE_WORKS.ko.md` — KEEP
|
|
- **Purpose**: Korean roadmap of pending improvements (FW-P1~P7, FW-W1~W7, FW-D2~D4 open; FW-D1 resolved).
|
|
- **Status**: Active backlog — most items remain unimplemented (e.g., FW-P6 root-marker detection, FW-P7 monitor HMAC hardening). Maintained mirror of `FUTURE_WORKS.md`.
|
|
- **Justification**: This is the project's only backlog tracker; deletion loses planned work. (Same verdict for the English `FUTURE_WORKS.md`.)
|
|
|
|
### 5. `DONE.md` — KEEP
|
|
- **Purpose**: Verified completion record for 28 items (FW-01~FW-16, FW-L1~L3, FW-N1~N7, FW-W3) with per-item commits and 3-agent cross-verification results.
|
|
- **Status**: Static historical record; explicitly linked from `FUTURE_WORKS.md:4` ("For completed items, see `DONE.md`") and its Korean twin.
|
|
- **Justification**: Deleting it dangles the FUTURE_WORKS reference and erases the audit trail mapping FW-IDs to commits. Zero maintenance cost. (Same for `DONE.ko.md`.)
|
|
|
|
### 6. `session_isolation_discussion.md` — DELETE, **but only with link cleanup** (amendment to Cline)
|
|
- **Purpose**: Rev.3 consolidated design discussion for the session-ID isolation feature.
|
|
- **Status**: Superseded — the doc itself declares `implementation_plan.session_isolation.md` (Rev.3) the single source of truth, and the feature is fully implemented, integration-tested, and PASSed by both reviewers (commits through `dad99f5`).
|
|
- **Amendment**: Cline's report misses that **two live tracked docs still link to it**: `implementation_plan.session_isolation.md:6` (관련 자료) and `task.session_isolation.md:3` (기준 문서). Standalone deletion creates dangling links.
|
|
- **Recommendation**: Treat the whole isolation doc set (`session_isolation_discussion.md`, `Problem_Definition.md`, `implementation_plan.session_isolation.md`, `task.session_isolation.md`, `session_isolation_handover.md` — the latter four out of this brief's scope) as one unit: either delete/archive them **together** (the feature is done and PASSed; the durable outcome lives in `.agents/reports/*/report-isolation-review.md` and git history), or if only the discussion doc goes now, remove the two inbound link references in the same commit.
|
|
|
|
### 7. `AGENTS.md` — KEEP
|
|
- **Purpose**: Core behavioral guidelines for all agents; entry pointer to `.agents/MULTI_AGENT_RULES.md`.
|
|
- **Status**: Active and essential — copied to target projects by **both** installers (`scripts/install_mam.sh:127,138` and `deploy/install.sh:131`), referenced by README and the orchestration rules.
|
|
- **Justification**: Deleting it breaks both install paths and the documented onboarding flow.
|
|
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
## Out-of-Scope Observations (for the record)
|
|
|
|
1. The root holds **18** markdown files; the brief covered 7. The undiscussed siblings share the fates above: `*.ko.md` twins follow their English counterparts; the four other session-isolation docs should be dispositioned as a set with #6.
|
|
2. The uncommitted working-tree `.gitignore` change adding `.agents/reports` (flagged in my installer verdict) is still present and would ignore the very reports directory this brief writes into — it should be resolved before committing any deletions.
|
|
3. Deletions of tracked files require `git rm` + commit; per standing constraints I have not deleted or committed anything — this report is analysis only.
|
|
|
|
## Final Verdict
|
|
|
|
**PASS on Cline's analysis with the §6 amendment**: 3 DELETE / 4 KEEP confirmed; `session_isolation_discussion.md` must be deleted together with cleanup of its two inbound links (or as part of archiving the whole isolation doc set).
|